Metal Roof vs Shingles: What is the difference?
As a homeowner, you know how important it is to choose the right roofing system. With so many options available in the market today, it is easy to get really confused. But when you make a decision, you should keep in mind the cost-effectiveness, durability, aesthetics and the overall effort that goes into maintaining the roof. There are many types of roofing systems that you can choose from. However, metal roofs vs shingles are a common comparison and to analyse which one is the best for you, you need to know various aspects of both. In this article, we have analysed both types of roofs objectively and instead of intense confusing information about both type of roofs, we have described defining aspects of each of these roofs. This is will help you make a more informed decision.
But before you go through the defining aspects of each of these roofs, it is important to know the difference between the two. While the most obvious difference is the material that metal roofs and shingle roofs are made of, there is a difference in aesthetics and durability as well. Because of the material, metal roofs may have more reflective qualities while shingle roofs may give a matte look. Aesthetically, both types of roofs come with various finishes that can give your house a desirable and pleasing look. By and large, homeowners prefer shingle roofs for a victorian look and metal roofs for a modern look. It is important to know that you get any look you want from either of the roof materials because of the finishes available in the market today. But it all boils down to the functionality and features offered by these roofs.
Another important thing to know that between the two roofs, one is better than in some aspects and falls short in some other aspects. This is why it is important to weigh your options objectively and be clear on what you as a homeowner expect from your roof.
Here are the various defining features of shingles vs metal roof:
Metal Roofs Are More Durable than Shingles
Durability is perhaps the most important aspect that you should base your decision on. It is a known fact that metal roofs are more durable and resistant to various forces of nature. This is why many companies offer a warranty of 30 to 50 years on their metal roofs. However, they do last for a minimum range of 40-70 years. While extreme hailing, snow, branches etc can dent these roofs, there are some sturdier options like steel roofs that you could choose from. You must also ensure that your roof is manufactured by a known manufacturer. Shingles on the other hand have a shorter lifespan due to their own unique set of weaknesses. In conditions of pooling water, damp weather can lead to the formation of algae and fungus growth that can reduce the durability of your shingle roof.
It is also not sturdy against sudden temperature spikes. However, in general, these roofs come with a warranty of 15 to 30 years but that depends on the manufacturer, the climate in your region and other environmental conditions.
Shingle Roofs Are Cheaper Upfront
When it comes to metal roofing price as compared to shingles, shingles are the winner. While planning your budget, it common for homeowners to go for a roof that is cheaper right off the bat. If your budget is limited for the time being, shingle roofs may be the better option. In the long run, shingle roofs may turn out to be a pricy affair. Metal roofs are definitely more expensive than shingle roofs and while they are comparatively more durable, you need to pay for that durability during the time of the installation. Metal roofs generally can run from $120 to $900 per 100 square feet (one 10-foot by 10-foot area, or a “square” of material), while asphalt shingles will be between $100 and $200 per 100 square feet. The installation of metal roofs is an additional cost because it is a specialised process. Following are some quick reasons why metal roofing costs may indeed be an investment in the long run:
- You may benefit from not having to replace metal roofs.
- Additionally, insurance companies may offer discounts to homes with metal roofs.
- In many areas, you may even qualify for tax credits by installing a metal roof on your primary home.
- Metal roofs conserve energy and may help to keep you on a budget with your monthly hydro bill.
Metal Roofs Are More Eco-Friendly
In this day and age, making eco-friendly choices is the responsibility of every homeowner. Sustainability is another common ground for shingles vs In fact, many real estates also value the sustainability value of a house. Metal roofs are more eco-friendly as they are largely made of recycled material and can be recycled, again and again.
With their reflective surface, metal roofs help conserve more energy. You can also choose from a range of coatings that help optimize the effectiveness of air conditioners and reduce carbon footprints. A major backstep for asphalt shingle roofs is that they need to be replaced more frequently than metal roofs and cannot be recycled. Moreover, the heavy reliance on petroleum for their manufacturing makes them an inferior choice when it comes to the environment.
Asphalt Shingle Roofs Generally Are Easier to Install and Repair
The installation process is an important parameter for some homeowners who are on strict timelines. If you want a quick roof installed, shingles are the choice for you. They can be installed in a day or two. In some cases, they can also be installed on an existing layer. Metal roofing on the other hand takes more time because of the specialized installation system. However, there are some lightweight varieties of metal roofs that can be installed right over an existing roof and that may take lesser time. If you have to replace metal roofs, that may be a longer and more complex process because of the way the panels are attached.
The pros of metal roofs often overpower their cons making it an obvious choice for homeowners. However, it is advised to take advice from a professional for your particular home. Now that you know various distinguishing qualities of metal roofs vs shingles, it’s time to choose the right company to get a hassle-free installation.
How Much Does A Metal Roof Cost Compared To Shingles?
There are metal roof vs. shingles cost differences. While a shingled roof can on average be expected to cost around $9000 (per 1000 sq/feet), the metal roof has an average expected the cost of $16000 (per 1000 sq/feet). The major factor in the cost of metal roofing comes with the labour involved in its installation. In order to ensure that the roof retains its longevity and durability, have a professional metal roof specialist install it. Doing so will make the installation process much faster, saving you money spent on labour time.
Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs Over Shingles
Despite the initial negative of the higher cost, the reasoning behind purchasing a metal roof becomes clear with the list of benefits that come with it. The average lifespan of a metal roof can be over 50 years depending on the material, more than doubling or tripling the lifespan of a shingled roof. This effectively multiplies your investment and ensures that there will be no need for drastic repairs or replacements for a very long time. The metal roof is a far more durable source of protection against the elements, particularly hail, wind, and snow, than a shingled roof.
Is Steel Roofing Better Than Shingles?
Whether you are looking for a new roof for a new home or in the market for replacing an old one, you might have doubts of steel roof is better than shingles?
- Style: Modern metal roofs come in a variety of colours and styles which gives you an opportunity to style it to match your exterior design. Asphalt shingles are not that much versatile.
- Cost: As for the steel roofing cost – yes, it is more expensive than asphalt shingles. However, when you look at the life-cycle costing, you will see that it is much more budget-efficient to invest in something more durable and reliable as a steel roof. Steel roofing will last you from 40 – 70 years with occasional care compared to 12-20 years of asphalt shingles.
- Energy Efficient: A steel roof will reflect the rays of the sun, thus keeping your home cool on hot days. Your new steel roof will keep money in your pocket by reducing your air conditioning costs by 10-15%. The roof that keeps on giving! In contrast, heat goes literally through asphalt shingle.
- Durable: Protect your home from harsh Toronto weather with steel roofing. Compared to asphalt shingles, steel is: able to withstand winds, will not crack against impact, and will not ignite due to fires or lightning. Best of all, this means that your roof will not require as much maintenance like other roofing materials!
In other words, it is a validated decision replacing a shingle roof with a steel roof.
Is Steel Roof Noisier than Asphalt Shingles?
Many people misjudge, assuming that a steel roof is noisier on a rainy day than asphalt shingles. The truth is that steel roofs are installed on your roofing surface with a sheathing in between. This additional layer absorbs excessive sound and effectively reduces the noise from rain and hail. Besides, steel roofs provide better protection against harsh Ontario weather than asphalt shingles. So, when it comes to metal roof vs. shingles, steel is definitely easier on the ears.
The Bottom Line about Metal Roof vs. Shingles
With the significant improvements that come with the installation of metal roofing, it is far worth the increase in cost over its efficient alternative. Metal roofing is an investment in your home that can repay itself both in the protection that it provides and the value that it brings to your home.